Skip to content
Figures for 2026 audited · Free calculators · Care providers in your area Assess care needs in 5 minutesMy Care CentreDeutsch
Care reform

Care managers assess Warken’s reform proposal: approval of the details, criticism of the lack of structural reform

The draft reform proposed by Federal Health Minister Nina Warken continues to spark intense debate within the care sector. Care sector leaders recognise some practical approaches, but at the same time warn that, without genuine structural reform, the planned care reform will primarily address the symptoms rather than the root causes.

WhatsAppFacebookEmail

Care managers assess Warken’s reform proposal: approval of the details, criticism of the lack of structural reform

The debate over the Care Reform Act has reached a new level. Following the initial wave of outrage from health insurance funds, associations, social policy makers and local authorities, senior managers from care homes are now increasingly speaking out. Their assessment is more nuanced than the general political criticism: not every point in the draft is rejected outright, but the core criticism remains clear. The aim is to stabilise long-term care insurance without truly resolving the long-term structural problems in the care system.

From the perspective of many care managers, this is crucial. Every day, care homes are caught between rising staff costs, time-consuming documentation, tough negotiations over funding, a growing shortage of skilled staff, higher quality standards and the financial limits of many people in need of care. A reform that merely increases revenue or curbs expenditure in the short term cannot permanently address this reality. That is why the draft is being assessed not only as a financial package, but also as a practical test for the future of care.

The key message from the world of care is this: individual measures to ease the burden may help, but they are no substitute for sustainable structural reform. Care facilities need reliable funding, less bureaucracy, clear lines of responsibility and a care policy that takes a holistic view of community care, residential care and family carers.

Why care managers still view certain aspects positively

Several decision-makers from the care sector are taking a pragmatic view of individual parts of the draft reform. Approaches that promise greater flexibility in day-to-day organisation are viewed particularly favourably. These include discussions about less rigid guidelines, greater scope in the provision of care, and a stronger focus on prevention before the need for care progresses further. The question of whether certain standards in care homes are always absolutely necessary or whether they simply drive up costs is also being discussed in practice, and not just in negative terms.

Operators of care homes and home care services, in particular, have found for years that political requirements are often well-intentioned but, in day-to-day practice, result in new costs, new documentation requirements and new administrative procedures. If the draft reform allows for greater flexibility in certain areas, this could certainly be helpful from the perspective of the care providers. The crucial question, however, is whether such approaches actually benefit staff, care provision and residents, or whether they remain merely on paper.

Practical approval

Some care managers see opportunities in greater flexibility, less rigid guidelines and a stronger focus on prevention. This can help care homes if it is implemented in a legally compliant and unbureaucratic manner.

General criticism

The major concern remains that the draft will provide short-term relief for the long-term care insurance system, but will shift the costs and risks onto those in need of care, their relatives, local authorities and care facilities.

The lack of structural reform remains a sore point

The main point of criticism concerns the lack of structural reform. Social care insurance remains a partial benefits scheme. It does not cover the full cost of care, but pays fixed benefit amounts. Anything beyond that is borne as a personal contribution by those in need of care or is covered by social assistance. This fundamental principle explains why any rise in costs in care homes and care services immediately becomes a social issue in the political arena.

Care managers therefore point out that the reform must not be allowed to solve merely a budgetary problem. What is needed is a system that brings together staff retention, training, community care, residential care places, short-term care, day care, digitalisation and the role of relatives. If changes are made to these areas in isolation, new gaps will emerge. Despite the reform, those in need of care will then continue to face complicated application processes, limited benefit amounts and costs that are difficult to calculate.

This becomes particularly clear when considering the interplay between care home costs and local authority social assistance. If financial relief for care home residents is spread out over time or if grants come into effect later, expenditure under the care insurance scheme does indeed fall in the short term. At the same time, however, the number of people who have to apply for care assistance may rise. This means that costs do not disappear, but are simply shifted elsewhere. It is precisely this shift that many stakeholders criticise as a lack of sustainability.

Care levels, personal contributions and relatives at the centre of the debate

The draft reform is also viewed so critically because several planned changes could directly affect vulnerable groups. Under discussion are stricter eligibility criteria for care levels, a delay in relief from personal contributions in care homes, higher contributions for childless people and lower pension contributions for family carers. In practice, these are not abstract figures. Every change alters counselling sessions, cost estimates and families’ expectations.

If it becomes more difficult to qualify for care levels, this may affect access to care services. If pension contributions for family carers are reduced, home care will be less well protected socially. If relief allowances in care homes come into effect later, the financial risks will increase for people who require long-term residential care. Leaders in the care sector see this as a particular responsibility for policymakers: those who wish to strengthen home care must not, at the same time, weaken the position of family carers. Those who wish to relieve the burden on care homes must not leave those in need of care to face unpredictable out-of-pocket costs on their own.

Further background information on the Care Portal

What care homes now expect from politicians

Care homes expect, above all, reliability from the reform. Staff planning, investment, pay negotiations and quality improvement require a long-term framework. Short-term cost-cutting targets or temporary relief measures are of limited help if care homes do not know how funding, service provision regulations and staffing requirements will develop over the coming years.

Added to this is the bureaucracy. Many care staff and management teams report that documentation, evidence, audits and billing issues take up a large proportion of their working hours. Any reform aimed at improving care must therefore also reduce the administrative burden. What matters is not the announcement of a reduction in bureaucracy, but whether care staff actually gain more time for residents, patients and their relatives.

For home care, it is also important that services can be combined more flexibly. Families often do not need a rigid, one-off service, but rather a mix of basic care, support, respite care, day care, short-term care, advice and spontaneous help in crisis situations. A modern care policy would need to reflect this reality of life more closely. Otherwise, entitlement to services remains in theory, but is difficult to access in practice.

Political assessment: reform or austerity package?

The key political question is whether the Care Reorganisation Act is perceived as a genuine care reform or, above all, as an austerity package. The Federal Ministry of Health emphasises that the aim is to stabilise the finances of the long-term care insurance system and improve care provision. Critics, however, argue that many of the measures will initially create burdens: higher contributions, delayed subsidies, reduced social security cover and new barriers to accessing benefits.

Feedback from care managers shows that the sector takes a nuanced view. Practical improvements are recognised, provided they can be realistically implemented. At the same time, there are still high expectations that the legislator will not merely tinker with individual aspects, but will fundamentally ensure that long-term care insurance is fit for the future. This requires fair funding arrangements between contributors, taxpayers, the federal states, local authorities, those in need of care and service providers.

Feedback from the care sector is mixed: from the perspective of some care managers, Warken’s draft reform contains some sensible approaches, but falls short of the requirements for genuine structural reform. As long as issues such as funding, personal contributions, protection for relatives, staffing requirements and bureaucracy are not resolved collectively, long-term care insurance will remain vulnerable to new crises. It will therefore be crucial for those in need of care, their relatives and care homes whether the draft is significantly improved during the legislative process.

Share, print or save this post

WhatsAppFacebookEmail

What are you entitled to?

With our free calculators, you can see in just a few minutes what care level you can expect and what amounts the long-term care insurance fund will pay.

  • Amounts for 2026 under SGB XI
  • No registration required and no personal data required
  • Printable result for assessment

Did you know?

This page was translated automatically with DeepL. If in doubt, the German version applies.

Check care levelCalculate care allowance